Maguire's Bay Front Restaurant

Reviews about Maguire's Bay Front Restaurant

• 2 / 5

  By Bill Benner
  We have eaten here on several occasions while on Fire Island, and up until this past Friday evening, always had good experiences. Unfortunately, our family dinner was ruined by a server who was angry and annoyed from the beginning. She was rude, curt, and extremely condescending on multiple occasions. She spent less than a minute going over the meal and drink options, seemed annoyed that we asked her to repeat the specials for someone who was not there when we were first seated, and generally disgusted with anything to do with our table. A person like this should not be waiting tables for a living if it's not what they want to do. We paid our $500 check, and even left an above average tip in spite of the fact that she deserved nothing. And yes, it is possible she had a bad day, and we just happened to be at the wrong place at the wrong time, but when I mentioned this to the owner, he apologized, said he would speak to her, but also said he was surprised because she was one of his best servers. With that, I realized there was really nothing else to talk about. I'm not one to write reviews on Google, but this time it was absolutely necessary. Hopefully the owner will read this, and realize my two-minute conversation last night should have been taken more seriously. Enjoy your meal!
  March 27, 2017